Painted Porch Rental on Cayuga Lake

02/28/2026

We have reduced spring and summer rates and minimum night stays for the few windows that are still available:

Here are all of the available weekend windows for SPRING:
April 14-21 (min 3 nights)
April 29-May 4 (min 3 nights)
May 7-May11 (min 3 nights)
May 14-May 18 (min 3 nights) ITHACA GRADUATION
May 28-June 4 (min 3 nights)

Available windows for Summer:
June 15 -18 (mid week, min 2 nights)
June 29-July 2 (mid week, min 2 nights)
July 20-23 (mid week, min 2 nights)
Aug 10-14 (mid week, min 2 nights)
Aug 25 - Labor Day!!! recent cancellation!!!! 5 night min

Please feel free to share!

05/03/2025

Replaced the old bathroom from the 50’s! Goodbye mustard tile and cramped space: Hello spacious luxury! Painted Porch Rental on Cayuga Lake welcomes you! Listed on VRBO #818041.

05/03/2025

The Painted Porch Rental on Cayuga Lake has updated 3 of its bedroom suites!! Enjoy Lake Life at our beloved farmhouse in Upstate New York, in the Finger Lakes Wine Region!

03/27/2025

Late cancellation for 4th of July week. I can't afford not to rent it that week, but I wanted to reach out to friends, family and fans of the Painted Porch in case anyone is interested. PM me if you are interested. And definitely share this post.

06/11/2024

Summer is only a few days away! The Painted Porch is ready for you! We still have 12 days available in August. Come and enjoy the lake!

05/22/2024

We had a cancellation in August, and we are coming home earlier than expected! So, the Painted Porch is AVAILABLE suddenly from August 5th to August 28th! I have reduced the rates by 20%, so NOW is the time to book for the BEST MONTH on Cayuga Lake. Go to VRBO listing 818041.

01/27/2024

This morning was a reminder of why even January is a great time to stay at the lake! Painted Porch Rental on Cayuga Lake

05/18/2022

We agree with our neighbors, Cayuga Shoreline! The food is incredible and the wonderful proprieters are my high school hockey coach's granddaughter and her husband! Don't let the big ice cream cone fool you....incredible hand crafted meals with exceptional composition and incredients are right inside the door!
AND...there's ICE CREAM!

05/05/2022

Spring is officially here and the Painted Porch is ready for your visit! There is a new week available in August! And there is a week in early June! Check out our listing on VRBO (818041) Did I mention we just had air conditioning installed!?

04/29/2022

Remember, the Painted Porch is next to an extraordinary event venue Cayuga Shoreline next door. Not to mention the best lakeside pub O'Malley'S Cabin on the Lake just a few doors away. Just another two great reasons to visit us at the Painted Porch!

Our farmhouse and cottages can sleep around 25-27 people, but we know that’s not always enough room. We have good news - our neighborhood is chock-full of vacation rentals! The one in this photo is our lovely neighbor. So if you want all of your guests in one place for your wedding weekend, just ask us for a list of local rentals and B&Bs.

03/09/2022

The Big M is the closest grocery store to the Painted Porch Rental on Cayuga Lake. They pack an amazing assortment of delicacies into a small space! LOVE THE BIG M!

Spring is in the air (except for the alleged snow storm Saturday!). Now is the time to plan your Seneca Lake Wine Trail adventures! Pencil in the Big M for your snacks on the trail- we’ve got you covered!