12/17/2023
First Solo playthrough of Three Sister
Final score: 72
π«π½π Review ππ½π«
Initial impression: It was more involved than I anticipated, but I recognize that is its appeal. It's a challenging and well-designed roll and write game, but maybe not the best fit for people who rarely play mid-weight games. I'll definitely play it again, but plan on a potentially much longer game with new players.
Ease of Learning:
This is not a game that you can learn with a quick overview. I had to refer to the rules repeatedly throughout my first game, and I still messed up a few important things and had to start over twice. However, the basic gameplay is such that, if you're willing to go slowly, you are more than able to learn as you play. I could see it taking people like me at least 3 games to really solidify the specifics of the different gardening areas.
*I realized just now I messed up another rule, so I likely should have scored lower. There are so many details!*
Gameplay:
Once you have the rules down, this game is very straightforward and fun. You set up each round by rolling the dice and placing them in ascending order on the rodel. You'll then alternate with the automated Farmer Edith in picking dice, you to determine the gardening area that you'll plant/water each round plus and the rondel action to take, she to block your options. The round finishes with an event that benefits you. This repeats for 8 rounds, then you sum your total points earned.
Like other games that don't have much player interaction, it works well as a solo game.
Aesthetic: The artwork is spot on for the theme. Clean, attractive, organized, green... you know, everything I aspire to be. The colors are vibrant but not overwhelming and the overhead view is neat and satisfying to look at.
The solo side of the rondel board is initially a bit much. It's feels cluttered to me, but at the same time, once you understand the symbols, it is a helpful reference guide. I do wonder if there was a better way to display it all, though.
Final thoughts:
Try it! See if it's your cup of tea.