08/19/2026
Here is a list of restaurants that are open here on Sanibel.
With more than 50 options to choose from, some old favorites and some new ones as well.... which is your favorite?
Bel’s Bagels
Bleu Rendezvous French Bistro
Blue Giraffe
Boops by the Bubble Room
Breezer’s Pool Bar
BRGR Kitchen + Bar
Bubble Room
Cantina Captiva
Captain’s Cafe
Captiva Crust Pizza
Captiva Island Pizza
Cheeburger Cheeburger
Cielo Restaurant
Crow’s Nest at Tween Waters
Dante’s Italian Kitchen
Doc Ford’s Rum Bar & Grille
Dunes Restaurant
Gramma Dots
Great White Grill
Green Flash
Huxters Market
Island Panda
Island Pizza
Island Time Bar & Grille
Jerry’s Grocery, Café and Coffee Shop
Keylime Bistro
Lazy Flamingo
Lighthouse Cafe-* now open for dinner too
Love Boat Ice Cream
The Magic Bus Ice Cream and Caffeine
Market Cafe
Mudbugs
Old Captiva House at Tween Waters
Over Easy Cafe
Pinocchio’s Original Italian Ice Cream
RC Otter’s
Rosalita’s Cantina
Sanibel Cafe
Sanibel Deli and Coffee
Sanibel Grill
Sanibel Sprout
Scooter’s Pizza
Shell City Burgers
Shipyard at Tween Waters
Starbucks
Sunshine Seafood Cafe
The Shack
Thistle Lodge Beachfront Restaurant
Shima Japanese Steakhouse & Sushi Bar
Subway
Timbers Restaurant & Fish Market
Traders
Turtle’s Tiki Bar
Tutti Pazzi Italian Kitchen
Wickies Lighthouse Restaurant
