07/16/2022
I watched the new Persuasion in Netflix last night. My advice is, don’t bother.
Persuasion is a classic. A delightful romance with a happy ending. Set in a time from the past where heroes in dashing uniforms and young ladies in charming gowns manage to find happiness despite the constraints of polite society. Why wouldn’t someone want to make such a movie? The question is
Who should be allowed to tamper with a classic?
There are reasons why something is a classic. It is universal and timeless. It is constructed, not unlike a beautiful symphony or a great opera, with many parts and transitions that need each other to make it hold together, balance, and be perfect. Jane Austen was a master of that art. There were never extraneous words. She had enough respect for her readers to let them know the characters by their words. She showed us their foibles subtly, but clearly and with delightful humor. She didn’t have to make her points repeatedly, have them explained.
This new movie entitled Persuasion is not Jane Austen’s Persuasion. It’s been dumbed down, ruinously modernized with inappropriate words and actions, and filled with extraneous words to explain what it could not portray through the characters. All humor was missing and several parts of the plot. The terrible reviews did not prepare me for how truly bad it is. There were times when I actually gasped at something a supposedly early nineteenth century person was doing. I didn’t get through the little trailer at the beginning without knowing the writer hadn’t a clue about proper behavior of that time when a man and complete stranger spoke to Anne as she walked along. The nonsense about seating at dinner was appalling. It was quite absurd to have Anne go for a swim, alone no less, when at that time even very few sailors could swim, much less a young lady. I could go on.
I believe I heard that the director, or maybe writer, intended to make Austen accessible to modern young people. All that was accomplished was possibly making those modern young people think Austen is nothing special. What a shame to completely miss the humor of the speeches by Sir Walter and his daughter Mary as they make themselves so foolish. What young people today need is to learn to think. The last thing they need is to have the character of Anne explaining everything to them. True, there is a narrator in much of Austen’s work, but a good writer of a screen play should follow the excellent example of Emma Thompson’s Sense and Sensibility and let the characters do the work with clever dialogue that illustrates who they are as they move the action along.
Some people shouldn’t be allowed to tamper with a classic. Much less trample a classic!